The Past Is A Foreign Country Meaning Essay

The Past Is A Foreign Country

In the past, things were different to the present day. Thus "the past is a foreign country- they do things differently there" is an accurate comment about New Zealand's Society in the last century. Many of these differences can be seen in the text, "Tu", by Patricia Grace. Firstly, one of the crucial differences was the way Maori families in rural New Zealand lived near each other in iwi groupings. Next, the place of religion was an important difference in New Zealand society, as more New Zealand families attended church regularly. Another important difference was the general frugal attitude to resources, where things were usually reused. Furthermore, society's attitude towards women was very difference, and this is another difference that will be discussed. Finally, the opportunity to travel was limited to a selected few, in the past, and many relatively poor people, including Maori, did not have a chance to go overseas.

Sixty years ago in New Zealand, many Maori families were grouped in rural areas according to their different iwis. This can be seen when Pita runs from his own home to his relatives' home in order to find "aunties" and "uncles" that could help him restrain his abusive father. He had "gone out over the bedroom window sill and ran to Uncle Willy's place", meaning that Maori families must have been living within walking distance. This is also shown by the place where another one of Pita's uncles lived. Pita "shuffled over the plank across the creek" in order to arrive at Uncle Juju's home, which would have been very close to his own home. The location of these homes was mostly rural as Pita had "hurried as quickly as he could through the swampy paddock that was holed by the feet of cows", and had "removed the long, muddy singlet that he was wearing, putting it in a bucket to soak and…washed the bog off his legs." This location can be contrasted to the present, where Maori are generally split up into nuclear suburban families. In addition, the Maori people, at present, generally live in more modern and suburban areas, which would have been unlikely in the past. Thus, in the past, the composition of rural Maori families was very different to that of the present.

The place of religion in the past was another important difference. Throughout the book of "Tu", both Tu and Pita have memories to do with the church, especially of Sunday Mass. His can be seen when Pita was "on his way home" but came near the "Sacred Heart Cathedral", where he went it, "crossed himself with holy water… and after a time he kneeled to pray." Another example is the memory Tu has of Sunday Mass: "…among concrete arches, statues and stations of the Cross; of red...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

Going Back in the Past: This is a process essay about my personal past.

741 words - 3 pages The fond memories that I had during my early years were memorable. I spent most of myadolescent years in forming close bonds with my basketball friends. Yet, school life inHong Kong was monotonous and mundane. The hectic schedule and numerous nights spenton studying took a toll on me, and I was exhausted. At that instant, I felt that I needed...

Is Human Spaceflight a Thing of the Past?

1396 words - 6 pages "That's one small step for a man, one giant leap for mankind." - Neil Armstrong (Dunbar). When Armstrong took those first steps on the moon he probably never realized that, in the future, people would be questioning whether we should continue spaceflight. Some question whether human space flight is worth all the money that goes into it. So why not send robots, others inquire, they are less expensive to send. Some question whether space flight is...

Definition of Living in a Foreign Country as an Immigrant.

637 words - 3 pages Living away from your country can be a really interesting and unforgettable experience, but at the same time it has very important influence on one's life. The purpose of this essay is to discuss what is to live in another country and being called an immigrant.The main idea of being an immigrant, and also a very common one, is that once you start a regular life away from home, you miss everything. This fact doesn't mean that you are...

The book, Distant Mirrors: America as a Foreign Culture, is

947 words - 4 pages The book, Distant Mirrors: America as a Foreign Culture, is a compilation of articles written by anthropologists, sociologists and professors. It was edited by Phillip R. DeVita and James D. Armstrong. This is the third edition of the Distant Mirrors books. In the introduction to the book it is said that Americans like things bigger and better and that is why they feel the need to keep making new editions. The main focus of this book is...

The Past and Future of Cuban Foreign Relations

1974 words - 8 pages Cuban politics has long been defined by foreign relations. One of the charges of the revolutionary leaders Fidel Castro and Che Guevara against Fulgencio Batista was his support from the United States of America. Batista was part of a military coup in 1933, and became President himself by election in 1940. His party lost the next election in 1944 after which he lived in the U.S., gaining allies. On his return to Cuba in 1952 he led a second coup...

This is a report for History on the country 'Colombia'

1480 words - 6 pages The Republic of Colombia is the fourth largest country in SouthAmerica. It is locatedat the north-western tip of the continent. Its neighbors are Brazil andVenezuela to the east,Panama to the north-west, and Ecuador and Peru to the south. Colombiais the only SouthAmerican country that's coast is on the

Slavery is in the Past

1952 words - 8 pages Imagine being out in the fields hunting with your father. It has been a long day and a spitted warthog hangs between you. All of a sudden you are ambushed! An enemy tribe attacks you and your father. You fight using your makeshift spear but are overwhelmed by the number of tribesmen. You are hit in the head with a rock and fall unconscious. When you wake you are being loaded into a great wooden monster. You cringe in fear as you and your fellow...

A Local Foreign Manager is Best for Managing Foreign Subsidiaries

550 words - 2 pages A Local Foreign Manager is Best for Managing Foreign Subsidiaries For many global organizations, or organizations that produce or sell goods or services in more than one country, a difficult question is how to develop and place managers in foreign operations. Some people believe organizations should let foreign managers run foreign subsidiaries because of the large differences among national cultures while others believe that domestic...

A Clouded Future. This essay discusses the current United States Foreign policy and the effects it will have on the country in the future.

2328 words - 9 pages A Clouded FutureIn the wake of September 11, 2001 numerous Americans as well as the global community began to question the validity of the United States claim to being the last superpower. With staunch facts put aside, referring to the strength of our economy as well as our military power, the United States seems to be at a loss for another entity that it can put assurance in. With seemingly endless problems arising for the United...

The Ulster Museum: Is It a Treasure or a Reaction to Its Turbulent Past?

2680 words - 11 pages Introduction pg. 2 Historical background of the Ulster Museum pg. 2 Context pg. 4 Description of spaces pg. 5 The Potential step forward pg. 5 Conclusion pg. 6 Bibliography pg. 7 Books pg. 7 Journals pg. 7 Internet pg. 7 Introduction This museum has been in transition at pivotal points of its historical time...

A Day In the Past

4877 words - 20 pages A Day In the Past "Bring" "Get up Mike!" his mother shrieked up the stairs. "oh no" groaned the reply because today as he knew all too well it was Monday, and not any Monday it was his first day back from the summer break. Gone were the days he could relax and enjoy the sunshine, He was now back to the real horror of life, the shocker of the year: School! He stood up wearily and yawned, stretching his long, thin arms...

The Past Is a Foreign Country, originally published in Great Britain in 1985, is an exploration of the nature of the past and history. What do we mean when we speak about the past, as distinct from the present or the future? What is the reality of the past? Is it the same as history? We have extremely varied attitudes about the past, although our range of attitudes is already determined to a large extent by our time frame and the local zeitgeist. People in different epochs have had ways of viewing the past very different from our own; their conceptions of it depended on the prevailing styles and beliefs of the periods in which they lived. An attitude toward the past, and assumptions about what it actually is—or was—are never constants; they vary greatly according to time, place, and other variables. Writers and ordinary people have always been fascinated by the passage of time. David Lowenthal’s study indicates the variety of attitudes toward the past from early periods with oral traditions to the present. He also includes a vast array of different sources: historians, novelists, poets, politicians, psychoanalysts, popular magazines, newspapers, cartoons, and publications of local historical societies. Although writers such as Petrarch, Michel de Montaigne, and William Shakespeare are quoted, so are the International Herald Tribune and The New Yorker; high culture and popular culture are combined in a mix providing a broad sociocultural panorama.

Because so many sources are quoted, The Past Is a Foreign Country sometimes gives the impression that the variety of attitudes toward the past, and history, is infinite. Often the author suspends his own judgment, letting the inhabitants of the past speak for themselves. At first glance, the ground covered appears to be complete, the treatment exhaustive: Lowenthal writes about different feelings and emotions provoked by the past, the various motives for the study of the past, benefits sought in the past, the threats it represents, tradition and innovation, notions of youth and age, decay and progress, methods for knowing the past, and ways in which the past is changed or preserved. To provide more focus at the beginning of the book, four “case studies” are presented to show “how various epochs have endured and resolved the stresses of inheritance.” These are the Renaissance, seventeenth and eighteenth century England and France, Victorian Great Britain, and pre- and post-Revolutionary America. The studies are excellent. They convincingly show very different attitudes toward the past, as well as pasts conceived in almost totally different terms. The author has assimilated much of the abundant scholarship on these periods; the varied sources he quotes are always interesting and well chosen. This section is a joy to read.

Despite the apparent breadth of the study, there are, however, several narrower foci of interest. The historians quoted are largely British and American; the journals referred to are also British and American. French and German sources make fleeting appearances, but they are rare. There is almost no consideration of Eastern Europe and Marxist or Communist countries and very little discussion of the Third World. This is a pity, as they would have added much more drama, especially to the treatment of historiography. Nevertheless, perhaps it is a virtue that the author focuses on Great Britain and the United States—as it is, there are more than two thousand footnotes in the book. Also the approaches of the British and Americans toward the past are radically different; there is abundant material to show contrasting attitudes within the same temporal periods.

A more specific focus in the book is revealed by the title. “The past is a foreign country” is a phrase from a book by L. P. Hartley, The Go-Between, published in England in 1953. The complete sentence which begins Hartley’s book reads: “The past is a foreign country; they do things differently there.” Lowenthal adds:That they did indeed do things differently is a perspective fundamental to this book. But it is a perspective of recent vintage. During most of history men scarcely differentiated past from present, referring even to remote events, if at all, as though they were then occurring.

A second theme that runs throughout the book is Lowenthal’s disagreement with the British historian J. H. Plumb. In his The Death of the Past (1969), Plumb made an important distinction between history and the past. According to Plumb, the “old past”—with its mythical fetishes of bigotry, national vanity, and class domination—was dying, while history, playing an emancipatory role, was assuming its place. Lowenthal takes issue with Plumb and refuses the distinction.

Both these themes rely heavily on British rather than American evidence. Because of the cultural differences between the two countries, American readers will have difficulty in accepting Lowenthal’s arguments. He admirably evokes the varieties of pasts with which writers and ordinary people have been confronted in different epochs. The convenient distance of the classical past from the Renaissance, which did not overpower writers such as...

(The entire section is 2141 words.)

0 Replies to “The Past Is A Foreign Country Meaning Essay”

Lascia un Commento

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *